Consider the Side Effects First: University Professor and NCAA Governance Leader, Dr. Tim Coffey, on Vetting Performance Tech and Protecting Athlete Data

Updated: Oct 29

Dr. Tim Coffey, biomechanist, Longwood University Associate Professor and Faculty Athletics Representative, and NCAA governance leader, talks with Kristy Gale, HonorDRM CEO, about asking the right questions before buying performance tech, and why educating athletes and team staff determines whether any of it works

In September, Dr. Tim Coffey participated in the NCAA Sport Science Institute’s education session, “SSI Spotlight on Performance Technologies.” This discussion focused on considerations and NCAA Recommendations for teams and administrators who evaluate and adopt athlete performance technologies. He and the other panelists - Dr. Deena Casiero, NCAA Chief Medical Officer and Senior Vice President of the Sports Science Institute and Dr. Mark Coberley, Iowa State University Senior Associate Athletic Director Sports Medicine - shared insights from their research among university medical, training, and coaching teams.
Dr. Coffey was kind enough to talk with me about his work and what drives him in an interview for our newsletter this month. Tim is personable and gracious, quick to share what he has learned, and happy to help others learn from his experiences.
When I asked him what sparked his interest in biomechanics and how he arrived at his position as a professor and advisor, he said it began with his own experience as an athlete with an injury.
Tim's path started with a high school sports injury and long stretches with orthopedic surgeons and physical therapists. As a result, he initially decided to pursue a career as an orthopedic surgeon. But in his sophomore year of college he found biomechanics. Tim liked the idea of building, taking things apart, figuring out how they worked, and understanding how the body moves like any machine, without someone having to go under the knife. So, he decided to pursue an interdisciplinary undergraduate degree in mechanical engineering and biology, then a master's in biomechanics at Texas Tech, studying ACL injury risk and 3D motion analysis under fatigue.
In a surprise twist, he moved into student affairs at Texas Tech and then at Virginia Commonwealth University where he finished his doctorate in 2015. His dissertation used 3D motion analysis to attempt to identify injury risks in high school athletes. While this data collection was rather laborious much of that work markerless motion capture can now do on a phone or laptop in about 30 seconds.
Importantly, Tim’s experience in student affairs helped him consider the student athlete perspective and make each student athlete’s experience a priority. This has shaped his approach when advising sports performance staff who are considering what performance technologies to adopt. He incorporates his experiences in his biomechanics and health fitness management courses at Longwood University where he has taught for 12 years.
Tim also serves as Longwood's Faculty Athletics Representative. Nationally, he has represented the Big South on the NCAA Division I Council, chaired the NCAA DI Strategic Vision and Planning Committee, and served as the Division I governance representative on the Committee on Competitive Safeguards and Medical Aspects of Sports. His resume speaks for itself and demonstrates his deep involvement in finding the best solutions for athletes and athletic department staff.
From the Training Room to the Lab to the Athlete Management System
When asked about the current state of performance tech adoption and data collection and protection, Tim points out that athletic departments collect more student athlete data than ever. They use lab grade equipment, GPS vests and other wearables, and motion capture that runs on a phone, to name a few. It was recently reported that the University of Florida holds more than a trillion data points on its student-athletes, combining GPS, neuromuscular, injury, recovery, and academic data in one database. Other programs keep their athlete data on laptops assigned to a strength and conditioning coach or another staff member.
The volume of data that is collected keeps climbing. What student athletes know about that data, and what the staff reading it understands, hasn't kept pace. So there are gaps to address.
Tim’s work focuses on studying performance tech and its uses by athletic department staff, advising them, and recommending student athlete-centric approaches to using the tech and collecting the data.
Tim said he sees this from three perspectives at once: biomechanics, Faculty Athletics Representative, and NCAA committee member. His advice to athletic departments is consistent. Collect with a purpose, and educate everyone who touches the data, starting with the student athletes.
Start With a Research Question
Tim evaluates performance technology the way he'd design a study. Before you collect anything, decide what question the data is attempting to answer. Does squatting before practice change a pitcher's velocity? That's a question you can test. Capturing as much data as possible then hoping a pattern turns up wastes time and money.
Fast optical tools have made data collection easy. But because so many data points are collected, the answers can get lost in the sheer volume of information. In Tim's view, this is imprecise and cluttered compared with a research study style methodology.
The same concept applies to buying performance tech. Athletic departments are adding sport scientists and data analysts to plan this work, and that helps. The risk is a department buying shiny equipment off a salesperson's pitch without a roadmap for successful, long-term use of the tech and the athlete data it produces. With budgets tightening across college sports, every device should map to a specific problem someone needs solved.
Some Athletes Don't Want to Know
As performance tech is adopted, it raises serious ethical and legal questions about athlete data. For example, one of Tim's senior thesis students screened basketball players with the Landing Error Scoring System, a test for ACL injury risk. Two women's basketball players opted out. They didn't want to learn they were at high risk for an ACL tear, because they worried the knowledge would change how they played.
That choice rarely comes up in conversations about athlete data, and it should. Mandatory tracking that leaves athletes no say wears down the student athlete experience. Athletes relate to their data in different ways, and those differences are legitimate.
Tim sees the variation by sport and by career goal:
A Division I FBS football or basketball player expecting a pro career views data differently than a student athlete who is preparing for physical therapy school or a business career.
Track and cross-country runners who check pace on a Fitbit or Apple Watch tend to be more data-driven.
Kinesiology students know a particular heart rate or VO2 max doesn't automatically mean better performance.
A "32" Means Nothing Without Context
Some metrics explain themselves. For example, a post-practice weigh-in tells an athlete how much to hydrate, but a workload score of 32 can tell a wide receiver and an offensive lineman two different things, and an athlete handed that number with no context learns nothing from it.
Tim's survey work found that a significant portion of student athletes get no education about technology risks or how their data is collected. They learn what the device is and little about what it means for them. Another gap.
The literacy gap runs up the chain, too. Tim cited a study in which most strength and conditioning coaches using GPS systems couldn't accurately define acceleration. Staff who don't understand how a system works can't help or protect the student athletes wearing it.
Education for student athletes and staff is key. Tim believes nearly all of them would want a basic understanding of their equipment and how their data gets used. That understanding builds buy-in: athletes who know what the technology does invest in it – and even more so when they know how it helps them and they are involved in decision making.
In Tim's own lab, IRB-approved human subject research starts with education. Participants, often high school or recreational athletes, learn how their data is collected and see skeletal motion capture animations of themselves. This in turn helps them understand movement and how the technology works to measure and assess their movement. Then they leave understanding the value of the work. Not every lab or athletic department runs that way, and Tim hopes upcoming guidance from the NCAA Sport Science Institute will push the culture toward responsible use and student athlete inclusion.
Tim’s Takeaways:
1. Someone Has to Ask the Education Question
As Faculty Athletics Representative, Tim asks hard questions. Strength and conditioning and athletic training staff focus on training athletes and treating injuries; educating athletes about technology isn't their primary charge. In his role as the FAR, Tim can ask the question that otherwise goes unasked: have our student athletes been taught what this technology collects and why?
2. AI Is Fast. Check the Output, Then Check With Counsel.
AI speeds up processing, and Tim sees the value in that. He also sees a black box. Without someone on staff who has the technical expertise to check the results, nobody catches it when a model reports a 130 mph pitch, a number no human arm produces. There is a need for expertise to be able to ensure that the results from the technology are valid.
Compliance raises a second flag. University general counsels have raised serious concerns about the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) when staff enter athlete data into AI tools. Before a department runs student athlete data through any AI tool, it should confirm what its university's guidelines on AI and data privacy allow.
3. Who Owns the Trillion Data Points?
Centralized athlete data platforms are growing. Some DI universities have an entire database that manages all of its data. That sits at one end of the range. Many programs use platforms like Teamworks, and some still keep data on a coach's laptop or a department computer - the other end of the range. Ownership policies vary by institution and by IT guidelines, and storage security varies with them.
Tim cautions that size alone proves nothing. A database built without clear research questions holds a lot of data and answers very few of them. Departments also need settled answers on who owns the data, where it's stored, and who can access it.
Access on paper often falls short in practice. Professional women's basketball players in Europe have used privacy law to request their performance data and contract terms, and the files they get back are often raw data in formats they can't act on. The best solutions allow student athletes access to their data and give them true control over their data while teams and universities use athlete properties in a compliant way.
4. Treat Performance Tech Like a Prescription
While preparing for his sabbatical, Tim mapped every connection he could find between performance technology and the rest of an athletic department on a spider graph. The lines ran to staffing, education, mental health, legal compliance, and budgets. One device touches all of them.
The NCAA Committee on Competitive Safeguards and Medical Aspects of Sports reflects the same reality. Its 24 members are chosen intentionally across all three divisions: coaches, legal experts, team physicians, strength and conditioning staff, athletic trainers, and mental health professionals.
Tim points to Goals Gone Wild, a 2009 paper by Lisa Ordóñez and colleagues on the side effects of narrow goal setting, to frame the risk. He compares goals and performance technology to prescription drugs. They can be beneficial and treat a real problem. They also can come with a list of side effects, including narrowed focus and unintended consequences, that show up when nobody monitors them.
5. The Bottom Line
Tim's core takeaway is education, for student athletes and for the staff who collect and read their data. Every other safeguard depends on it. For athletic departments vetting their next piece of performance tech:
Name the research question before you sign the purchase order.
Budget for intentional, long-term use that lasts well past the launch.
Regularly tell student athletes what's collected, why, and what the numbers mean for them individually.
Respect the athlete who chooses not to know.
Verify AI outputs, and check with general counsel on FERPA before athlete data goes into any AI tool.
Settle ownership, storage, and access before the data piles up.
Athletes who understand their data invest in it. Departments that read the side effects first get the benefit of the technology without paying for what they didn't plan for.
Tim teaches biomechanics, health fitness management, and youth sports specialization at Longwood University. You can learn more about Tim and his work on his LinkedIn and you can contact him at coffeytg@longwood.edu.




Comments